A Santa hat or knitted Christmas cap is the easiest way to finish a baby's festive look. It also needs more thought than most accessories, because it sits on a soft head, close to the ears, and often stays on for hours of cuddles and photos. A hat that is slightly too tight, has a scratchy trim or presses on the ears can make a baby fuss, and then the pictures suffer. Here is how to pick a cap that fits well, feels soft and is easy to take off.

Measure the head before you buy

Many cap listings give a head size range or an age range rather than a fixed size. Age is only a rough guide, because babies of the same age can have quite different head sizes. If the listing gives a head circumference in centimetres, use a soft tape measure around the head, just above the ears and across the eyebrows, and compare the number with the chart. If you only have an age, check our size guide and then read the listing for words like "free size" or "adjustable". A free size cap sold for babies aged 3 to 18 months may suit many babies, but a close knit cap may not stretch enough for a baby with a larger head.

Check the fit around the ears

Ears are the detail most parents miss. A cap that is too small can press the ears down or pull on them, and a stiff brim or a tight seam can rub the edge of the ear. Look for a cap with a generous cut around the ears, a soft seam and a little give in the knit or velvet. After you put it on, gently check that the ears sit comfortably, that your baby can turn their head freely and that the cap is not pulling at the top of the ears. If your baby keeps pulling at their ears or seems sore after wearing a hat, take the hat off and speak to your doctor, because ear discomfort is a health question.

Choose soft linings and gentle fabrics

A cap sits against the scalp, so the lining matters more than the outer colour. Cotton and cotton blend linings are a common choice for everyday wear because they are breathable and simple to wash. Velvet and soft fleece look festive and feel warm, but check that the velvet is not the only layer touching the baby's head. Knitted caps are lovely for winter outings, though a thick wool knit may feel itchy on a sensitive baby. Keep the cap in step with the outfit underneath: babies should not be overheated, and a hat should not be the only warm layer in a cold room. Our fabric guide covers what to look for in each material.

Look closely at the fastenings

Most Santa caps close in one of three ways. Elastic bands are simple, but the band must stretch without digging in, and a band that is too tight can leave marks or make the cap ride up. Velcro closures are useful because you can set a snug but comfortable fit by hand, and you can loosen them as your baby's head grows. Ties and strings under the chin need extra care. They can loosen, tangle or be pulled, so skip them for a baby who will be lying down or left alone, even for a moment. Whichever closure you choose, check that any fastener touching the skin is covered in soft fabric and that there are no loose ends to pull.

Skip pom-poms, bells and loose trims

A pom-pom looks charming on a knitted hat, but it can come loose and become a small object a baby can grab and put in the mouth. Bells, sequins, beads and sewn-on appliques carry the same risk. Our earlier guide on safe Christmas accessories for babies covers the wider list of items to skip. For caps, look for a smooth brim, a neat seam and trims that are stitched on firmly, then check the cap after every wash, because stitches can loosen over time.

Hats for photos and parties

For photos, a soft red cap with a white trim gives a classic look with very little effort. Put the hat on just before the shoot rather than an hour before, so it does not sit on a warm, sweaty head for the whole session. Between shots, lift it off and check the ears and forehead for marks. At parties, keep a spare hat in the bag. Babies can get warm in a crowded room, and a hat that is comfortable at home may need to come off once the room fills up. Our size guide helps you match several children with different head sizes, and the Santa costume guide covers how a cap fits with the rest of the outfit.

Caps to look at

These listings have the features covered above. Check each one for the current price, stock and care instructions before you order.

FAQ

How do I know if a Santa hat fits my baby?

Compare the head size in the listing with a measurement around your baby's head, just above the ears. Then put the cap on and check that it sits comfortably, the ears are not pressed or pulled, and your baby can move their head without the cap slipping over the eyes. If the cap is tight across the forehead or leaves a red mark on the skin, choose a larger size.

Are pom-poms safe on a baby hat?

Pom-poms are best skipped for babies who put things in their mouth, because a pom-pom can come loose and become a small object. If you do choose a hat with a pom-pom, check that it is firmly attached, keep it for supervised photos and remove the hat once your baby starts pulling at the top of it.

Can a baby wear a cap all day?

A baby can wear a soft, well-fitting cap for a festive outing, but it should come off if the baby is hot, sweaty or uncomfortable. Always take the cap off for sleep and rest, and check the head and ears after the cap has been on for a while. If you notice redness, irritation or a baby who keeps pulling at the ears, speak to your doctor.

A good Christmas cap is soft, fits the head without pressing the ears and closes in a way you can check easily. Measure before you buy, keep the trims simple and take the hat off as soon as your baby is uncomfortable.